Obviously, you can't foresee all effects of either option (neither can I), so how can you rank them?

Being able to see all the effects (of anything) is too high a standard. Ranking options and choosing actions always goes forward with imperfect predictions and best judgement.

From what I can see, the iron approach isn't very attractive, but I'm glad that it was taken seriously enough to be investigated through open-sea experiments.

Words and ideas I offer here may be used freely and without attribution.