Welcome to European Tribune. It's gone a bit quiet around here these days, but it's still going.
Display:
Why is this? Why can't surplus core capital go somewhere else than into peripheral country debt (private or public)? Why can't it instead go into peripheral country equity,

There's basically four ways that could happen. Spanish firms could sell equity they hold in German firms. German firms can offshore production to Spain. German venture capitalists can seek to exploit promising business niches in Spain. Or German firms can buy equity stakes in Spanish firms.

The first option isn't really an option, because Spanish firms have no major equity stake in the German economy. And even if they had, why would they be inclined to sell it unless they were forced to? Shareholders in German firms have been the big winners in German policy.

Offshoring to Spain isn't going to happen either, for a couple of reasons. In the first place, any firm that is going to offshore is going to offshore to Eastern Europe or China. In the second place, the German reaction to offshoring would be to further depress domestic demand, further deflate prices and thereby force any business offshored to a €-zone country that was not prepared to follow Germany in a race to the bottom back into the fold.

And the problem for German venture capital seeking gains in Spain is that local Spanish investors are going to have an easier job of finding the good investments than ones operating out of Frankfurt.

Could German firms have obtained an equity stake in Spanish firms instead of lending Spain money? Obviously they could. And they probably did. But that isn't very much of an improvement - laundering the surplus into the secondary equity market would just be fuelling a stock market bubble instead of a real estate bubble.

By contrast, the way the debt was issued was that local Spanish banks made loans to Spanish households and businesses. The Spanish banks then went on the interbank market and borrowed regulatory reserves from German banks. Spanish households and firms then spent money back to Germany, forcing Spanish banks to borrow even more on from the German banks on the interbank market. Lending to other €-zone banks on the interbank market is virtually automatic, particularly when it is an interbank loan to cover a deposit transfer.

or outside the eurozone?

Because there is an intra-€-zone trade imbalance. If the surplus went out of the €-zone, the deficit countries would have to start borrowing outside the €-zone as well. Which would reduce to the current situation, but with a Chinese middleman between Germany and Spain.

Of course that might be politically easier, since you could then screw over the foreign middleman, rather than deal with the imbalances as a matter of internal policy. But I suspect that there's an upper limit to how long foreigners are willing to accept getting screwed over for the sake of internal €-zone cohesion.

And why must debt explode in the peripheral countries with trade deficits? Why can't they instead reduce their equity holdings,

In order to do that, surplus countries have to buy their equity. So this is simply a mirror image of your first question.

or reduce their imports from the core?

This one's actually the easiest question to answer.

All economic activity involves a proportion of imports. The precise proportion depends on how your economy works - what sort of raw materials you have, what sort of stuff you make, how your institutional structures are set up, that sort of stuff.

Reducing the percentage of your economic activity that depends on imports is hard, and takes time. One of the easiest ways to do it is to devalue your currency, but that option wasn't available. The second easiest option is to do hands-on import substitution policy. But that's illegal under EU rules.

So with no really desirable options for reducing import share, the only way to reduce total imports is to reduce domestic economic activity. That is, create an artificial business depression.

- Jake

Friends come and go. Enemies accumulate.

by JakeS (JangoSierra 'at' gmail 'dot' com) on Sat Dec 25th, 2010 at 05:01:53 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Others have rated this comment as follows:

Display:

Top Diaries

Occasional Series