Welcome to European Tribune. It's gone a bit quiet around here these days, but it's still going.
Display:
I know a few (russian) people, working in Russia, either in medium size or in very small businesses.

They all tell the same story : corruption is everywhere, at all levels, and make economic progress impossible. Just trying to work normally is an endless struggle.
They say there is no attempt from the higher powers at fighting it : just some feel-good operations on TV.

They hold Putin and generally the national and local authorities responsible for this state of affairs.
They do not believe this will change any time soon.

So yes, Putin is a failed leader.

by balbuz on Thu Jun 17th, 2010 at 12:25:16 PM EST
In the place where I have grown up there were not many Russians and I did not know any of them closely. Only when I was studying a short time in Moscow in early 1990s I got closer look and often I was startled at their habits. For example once I found my friend stealing lampball from corridor in university. I asked him why he's doing that, lampball is just few kopeks worth. He replied that the state was always cheating them and thus he pays back in the same coin.

So in a word Russians deserve fully leaders they elected. They like to complain about corruption but personally do next to nothing to fight it. Secondly corruption varies wildly according to regions and for example in my region (Sakha republic) small entrepreneurs do not face such problems. Thirdly corruption generally confined to relationships between the state and businesses (from licence Raj to building contracts) but comparatively less in delivery of essential public services like healthcare, education, heating, electricity, water supply etc.

When I moved to Asia I found that corruption here affects even basic services, many of them are non-existent (there is no universal health insurance, no social pensions, only private schools, no central heating, no gas, no hot water, very little and erratic power supply etc) or available only after bribing officials. I don't need to speak even about corruption in judiciary and state organs affecting private businesses.  

So not being Putin's apologist I disagree with his assesment as a failed leader, his track record is rather mixed, but nobody can deny that he was rather adroitful at maintaining macroeconomical stability and at accumulating financial reserves.

I remember when he came to power Financial Times greeted him with editorial where the paper claimed that post of President of Russia is the most unenviable job in the world, the scope of problems to solve was daunting.

Now it's not that clear, after Bush and Brown/Blair disastrous reigns posts of British PM and American president lost a lot of their former lustre while almost everybody in Russian polity wants Putin/Medvedev's jobs maybe just to plunder the treasury.

by FarEasterner on Thu Jun 17th, 2010 at 01:32:11 PM EST
[ Parent ]
Thirdly corruption generally confined to relationships between the state and businesses (from licence Raj to building contracts) but comparatively less in delivery of essential public services like healthcare, education, heating, electricity, water supply etc.

About essential public services, and remembering I am just repeating what "small people" say, this is where the worst degradation happened between the soviet times and now : drugs that used to be free and which are now paid for, miserable salaries for teachers with the best elements looking for a better fate elsewhere, etc.

What happens in small towns is that medical resources which used to be there (such as anesthesists) have just disappeared, so that unless one has the means to go get care in the larger towns, one's health is left to luck.

And after the jobs boom of a few years back, the situation has become quite grim again. I know of some young russians, educated in France, who couldn't adapt to the place, went back to Russia, but are now in a dead end over there : no jobs, no future.

I have no agenda, I don't have the overall view, but I can't help thinking resources don't go where they should, and authority is not applied where it should.

Now, the same can be said here, and I certainly won't say the western leadership is any better...

by balbuz on Fri Jun 18th, 2010 at 04:05:02 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Display:

Occasional Series